Published: 19.12.2018
In January, the Polish Office for Foreigners stated that family life protected by international law is at risk in this case. According to the officials, there were "objective reasons to assume that granting asylum to Mrs Silje Garmo and her minor daughter, Eira Garmo, is necessary to ensure the protection of the aforementioned foreigners". However, another opinion was issued by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, which decided that granting asylum protection to the woman and the child is not "in the interest of the Republic of Poland". The Ministry based this decision, inter alia, on an assessment of Polish political and economic interests. Therefore, the Ordo Iuris Institute submitted an application for reconsideration of the case by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs.
After several months, the decision to refuse asylum was revoked. This is the basis for the decision of the President of the Office for Foreigners. He had previously supported the plea of Ordo Iuris lawyers, so the finalisation of granting of asylum protection to Silje Garmo and her daughter is a purely formal issue.
In 2018, a report criticising the Norwegian Barnevernet system was adopted by the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe. The European Court of Human Rights, furthermore, ruled that the Norwegian system of foster custody infringes international guarantees of family life (Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights). The Ordo Iuris report on Barnevernet was presented in September during the OSCE conference in Warsaw.
‘The decision of the Minister of Foreign Affairs confirms that the Republic of Poland is firmly committed to upholding the fundamental constitutional principle of the protection of family life. The decision of Polish authorities is also a source of hope for Poles living in Norway, who often face the same problems as Silje Garmo. Asylum for a Norwegian mother and her daughter is an impulse for Norway, where there is still a debate about the need to reform the Barnevernet system. On a European scale, Poland is once again taking part in the debate on the protection of families persecuted by authorities such as Barnevernet or Jugendamt’, commented the President of the Ordo Iuris Institute, Jerzy Kwaśniewski, attorney of Silje and Eira Garmo.
The case for asylum was handled by the attorneys: Jerzy Kwaśniewski, Bartosz Lewandowski, PhD, Filip Wołoszczak and Maciej Kryczka.
24.05.2023
· The European Court of Human Rights has ruled that Romania violated the right to respect for private and family life of 21 same-sex couples who complained that their cohabitation could not be formalized.
· The complainants demanded payment of more than half a million euros in compensation for the "psychological suffering" involved.
· The Court ruled on the violation, but refused to award compensation.
24.05.2023
· The Lithuanian Movement of Families held an international conference in Vilnius this past weekend entitled. "Standing up for natural rights, let's save Europe together."
· The discussion at the event focused on emphasizing the value of the family and the fundamental right of parents to raise their children according to their own beliefs, as well as the dangers accompanying them due to technological advances, globalization and the promotion of gender ideology.
12.05.2023
· The European Parliament has passed a resolution agreeing to conclude the Istanbul Convention in its entirety for EU institutions and in part for member states.
· The document is controversial due to some provisions promoting gender ideology.
· The EU's accession to the convention would allow EU institutions to impose financial penalties on countries for "inadequate" implementation of its provisions.
12.04.2023
· The European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg has dismissed complaints against decisions by German civil registry offices that refused to enter information on birth certificates that did not conform to the biological sex of two people.
· The first case involved a woman who changed her metric sex from female to male on her documents and began hormone therapy. After stopping the therapy, she gave birth to a child conceived through in vitro fertilization.