Informujemy, że Państwa dane osobowe są przetwarzane przez Fundację Instytut na Rzecz Kultury Prawnej Ordo Iuris z siedzibą w Warszawie przy ul. Górnośląskiej 20/6, kod pocztowy 00-484 (administrator danych) w celu informowania o realizacji działań statutowych, w tym do informowania o organizowanych akcjach społecznych. Podanie danych jest dobrowolne. Informujemy, że przysługuje Państwu prawo dostępu do treści swoich danych i możliwości ich poprawiania.
Skip to main content
Facebook Twitter Youtube

American- Israeli scientist files his opinion to Constitutional Tribunal in Istanbul Convention case

Published: 02.02.2023

Adobe Stock

· Professor Eugene Kontorovich, Israeli lawyer specialized in constitutional and international law sent amici curiae (“friend of the court”) opinion in Istanbul Convention case to Polish Constitutional Tribunal.

· Legal argumentation presented by professor contributed to denial of the Convention by Israel.

· In his opinion Professor Kontorovich points that the Convention puts many obligations on state-parties, which execution may be problematic in democratic state of law.

· Author of the opinion also underlines that many of solutions accepted by the Convention are of ideological nature.




In 2020 Prime Minister Mateusz Morawiecki filed a motion to Constitutional Tribunal to examine of compliance of Istanbul Convention with the Constitution of the Republic of Poland. Proceeding is ongoing, and its opinion on the case filed also Ordo Iuris Institute, pointing that many of Convention provisions are extremely inconsistent with Polish basic act.


Professor Eugene Kontorovich, an Israeli lawyer, decided to file his opinion on the case to the Constitutional Tribunal. His legal argumentation contributed to denial of the Convention by Israel.


Eugene Kontorovich is a profesor of constitutional and international law. He earned his education at University of Chicago. He was also a lecturer in Northwestern University School of Law, and currently he is giving lecture in Antonin Scalia Law School of George Mason University. Moreover, he is head of international law department in Kohelet Policy Forum, the Israeli biggest think-tank. In his scientific and public activity he speaks about Istanbul Convention for many times.


As we can read in opinion of professor Kantorovich: The Convention is not just a treaty, it is a crusade. As the Council of Europe proudly states, the treaty is “a manifesto, laying down a vision of society in which … gender equality is fully achieved.” Unlike perhaps any other such international agreement, the Istanbul Convention has the express goal of remaking society. The Convention proceeds from a thesis that physical violence against women is not caused by the individual depravity of the perpetrators, but ultimately by distant “root causes.” These root causes include all social attitudes and traditions about the roles of men and women that cast men and women in differential, or “stereotyped” roles.


Professor also indicates that Convention is a danger to freedom of speech, can be a cause to rise of clear preferences for leftist NGOs, and also can lead to many other problems which can be tied to extended interpretation by the committee established to monitor its enforcement by state-parties, called GREVIO.


Family and marriage


Strasbourg Court: state has no obligation to recognize "third sex"

· The European Court of Human Rights has dismissed the complaint of a French man suffering from hermaphroditism who demanded that a notation of "neutral" or "intersex" gender be entered on his birth certificate.

· The courts refused, pointing out that his request was essentially a demand for the establishment of a "third gender," while French law only recognizes male and female sex.

Read more
Family and marriage


The defeat of "Atlas of Hate" and the victory of truth

The European Commission has been conducting a special "infringement procedure" against Poland since July 2021. EU officials claimed that Poland was discriminating against people with homosexual tendencies and experiencing "gender identity" disorders. Evidence of this discrimination was to be found in alleged "LGBT-free zones." This is an obvious lie by the LGBT activists themselves, who, by the way, openly boasted on social media that thanks to them the Commission is screening Poland.

Read more
Family and marriage


Bulgaria's Supreme Court: judicial "sex change" is impossible

· Bulgaria's Supreme Court has ruled that "gender reassignment" through legal proceedings is inadmissible under Bulgaria's current state of the law.

· The Supreme Court stressed that "gender is recognized at birth and defines a person until death."

Read more
Family and marriage


European Commission step toward forcing states to recognize same-sex parenthood

· The European Commission has drafted an EU regulation that would make it compulsory for EU states to recognize each other's decisions establishing parenthood.

· As a result, Poland would be obliged to recognize the legal force of a document certifying same-sex parenthood.

· The EU regulations are directly applicable - their provisions do not require implementation into the national legal order.

Read more